Season Two: Finale (2)

You turn your head.

Karina and Winter step out together.

Your girlfriend’s lips curve into a wicked, triumphant smile the second your eyes meet. Winter, on the other hand, looks ashamed, cheeks burning red, unable to meet your gaze for more than a second.

Your eyes narrow.

“Karina.”

Your voice comes out low and rough. She tilts her head, still smiling.

“Hey baby.”

She replies sweetly, like she didn’t just walk in on you creampying one of her best friends while the other is now eating your cum out of her.

You look at Winter. She shrinks slightly under your stare, biting her lip. The guilt on her face is obvious.

Did you get played by both of them?

The thought hits you hard. All this time, the teasing, the begging, the way Winter had been pushing so hard… Was Karina still pulling strings even after you faked your orgasm?

Ningning and Giselle finally notice the new arrivals. Ningning pulls her face away from Giselle’s pussy, lips shiny with a mix of your cum and Giselle’s juices. Her eyes go wide when she sees Karina and Winter standing there. Giselle sits up, still breathing hard, her face also covered in your dried load. She looks between Karina and Winter, shock written all over her expression.

But Karina’s smile doesn’t fade. She takes a slow step forward, eyes sweeping over the obscene scene - Ningning and Giselle on their knees, both marked and covered in your cum, your cock still hard and glistening from their juices and spit.

“Well…”

Karina says, voice dripping with amusement:

“Looks like someone lost a bet.”

You narrow your eyes.

“I only-“

Karina cuts you off before you can reveal that you caught her touching herself and losing first.

“Baby… I can’t even count how many times you came this month. With Irene unnie, with Seulgi unnie, with Joy unnie, with Yeri unnie… Should I keep going?”

You open your mouth to argue, but she raises a hand.

“And don’t even try the ‘I faked it’ excuse. Minjeong was only pretending to help you fake your orgasm… but she was on my side the whole time.”

Winter shrinks slightly beside her, cheeks burning red, unable to meet your eyes.

You feel a cold wave wash over you.

“You’ve gotta be kidding me…”

Karina pulls out her phone, taps a few times, and turns the screen toward you. It’s a video. The same night you thought you caught her touching herself. But this time the angle is different, clearly from a different camera. In the video, Karina is lying in bed, moaning softly… but her hand isn’t between her legs. She’s just pretending, rubbing her thigh, putting on a show. She even glances toward the door with a tiny, knowing smirk before continuing her fake moans.

Your stomach drops.

Karina locks the phone and puts it away, smiling brightly.

“You really thought I’d lose that easily?”

You stand there, stunned, slowly piecing everything together. Karina had looked way too confident the entire month. Winter had been pushing untypically hard to get you to fuck her. The way Winter and Karina almost looked like they knew things they shouldn’t have…

You rub your face with your hand, annoyed at yourself.

“I should’ve known. You were too smug. Winter was too eager…”

Karina walks closer, still smiling, and gently pats your chest.

“It’s okay, baby. You tried really hard this year.”

She leans in, voice dropping to a whisper.

“But you lost.”

Behind her, Winter shifts awkwardly, still looking guilty but also a little relieved it’s finally out in the open. Giselle and Ningning are both staring at the scene, wide-eyed, clearly processing everything that is going on. You don’t think either of them is involved and you can’t tell if they even knew what was going on between you and Karina until now.

The bet is over. And you lost. You stand there, still breathing hard, cock slowly softening as the reality of the situation sinks in.

Fuck.

You lost.

The disappointment hits you like a cold wave. All that effort… and Karina had been playing you the entire time. You rub a hand over your face again, annoyed at yourself for not seeing the signs sooner.

Karina watches you with that bright, victorious smile. She gently starts running a finger down your chest.

“You know what the punishment is, right? No cuming for the entire next month.”

You let out a long, defeated sigh.

“…Yeah. I know.”

Karina’s smile widens, clearly enjoying your reluctant acceptance.

“But until December starts…”

She continues, voice dropping into a teasing purr.

“You can do whatever you want. And right now, you have all four of us right here in this apartment.”

Before you can even respond, Karina turns her head slightly.